Tribunal: unincorporated associations are not companies for the purposes of FOIA

The question of whether a body is a public authority for the purposes of the Freedom of Information Act 2000 (FOIA) is determined by asking (up to) three questions:

1: is it listed in Schedule 1 to FOIA?
2: has it been designated as a public authority by order by the Secretary of State or Minister for the Cabinet Office?
3: is it a company wholly owned by the wider public sector, or by the Crown (or by both of those)?

If the answer to all of those is “no”, then the body is not a public authority, and it is not obliged to comply with FOIA, no matter how much it might seem or look like a public authority.

These issues arose in a recent case in the First-tier Tribunal, following a decision by the Information Commissioner’s Office that the Conference of Colleges of the University of Oxford (the “Conference”) – an unincorporated association – was not a FOIA public authority.

It is accepted that the University of Oxford is a public authority, as is each of the colleges of the University (see paragraph 53 of Schedule 1 FOIA). The appeal to the Tribunal was based on argument by the appellant (“The Association Of Precarious Postdoctoral Researchers Ltd”) that the Conference, being a body created by the constituent colleges, met the definition of a “company” wholly owned by those colleges. Although FOIA does not define “company”, certain other legislative provisions do, including section 1121 of the Corporation Tax Act 2010, pursuant to which it is defined as meaning “any body corporate or unincorporated association…”.

That argument, however – held the Tribunal – actually counted against the appellant, because in the absence of clear legislative intent to broaden the term for the purposes of FOIA, it should take its ordinary English use: “unincorporated associations are not considered to be caught by the normal definition of a ‘company’ and…Parliament will make express provision to include them where it intends to do”.

The views in this post (and indeed most posts on blog) are my personal ones, and do not represent the views of any organisation I am involved with.